Casey Punches

I founded Punches Law, APC to bring clear, efficient, and approachable legal services to Californians navigating life’s big transitions. Based in Paso Robles, I serve clients throughout San Luis Obispo County and beyond in two focused areas: estate planning and landlord representation.

I believe in solutions that are honest, strategic, and tailored — because every client’s story is unique. Whether you’re protecting your legacy or managing your rental property, my goal is to provide legal support that respects your time, your values, and your vision.

• Free Consultation
  We believe in every individual having an opportunity to be heard. As such, we offer free 30 minute consultations to determine if we would be a good fit with you, the client.
• Credit Cards Accepted
• Contingent Fees
  Depending on the type of case, we are happy to discuss the option.

California

State Bar of California

ID Number: 361665

Academic Excellence

San Luis Obispo College of Law

2025

During my time at law school, I managed to finish at the top of my class!

State Bar of California  # 361665

Member

Current

Q. Can a tenant countersue in a small claims appeal for a case won in CA?

July 23, 2025

A: Hello,

That's a great question! In almost every legal matter, the answer initially is "it depends," as many legal issues are complex in nature. That said, in most cases (including small claims cases), a party cannot raise new issues on appeal. The way the judicial system sees it, if they had the chance to raise it, but decided not to, they cannot typically raise it later. On appeal, the tenant in most cases cannot raise new information.